🎧 Reviewed by LD | Rating: 2.7/5 | Steam: 🔥 | Standalone
⚠️ This is a full spoiler review. If you haven’t read You Will Remember Nothing yet — go read it first. We’ll be here when you’re done.
The Opening
Here’s the thing. I went into this one wanting to like it. A destination wedding thriller set in Corfu, a suspicious death from ten years ago, a hypnotherapist dropping a bombshell right before the flight — that sounds like exactly my kind of book. And then I actually listened to it, and… yeah. It never quite got there for me.
The Full Story — Spoilers Included
The Setup
Rowan’s best friend Daphne is getting married. In Corfu. The exact place where, ten years ago, Daphne’s twin brother Chris drowned. He was Rowan’s boyfriend. Five of them went on that trip. Only four came home. Rowan has spent the last decade completely devastated by his loss, which is already a little complicated by the fact that they had only just started dating and hadn’t even slept together yet. I don’t say that to minimize her grief, but the scope of it is something the book itself asks you to reckon with.
So Daphne wants to get married in Corfu and Rowan is panicked by this, and she starts seeing a hypnotherapist to try to deal with it. One session. She doesn’t feel like it solved anything, and she doesn’t even remember what she said under it, and she figures it was probably a waste of time. She catches her flight. She’s going.
The Hypnotherapist Calls
While she’s out at the bar in Corfu the night she arrives, already pretty drunk, the hypnotherapist calls again. He tells her he cannot in good conscience continue treating her. She pushes back — she’s already paid — and he says he’ll refund her, but there’s a recording of her session he needs to send her, and what she said under hypnosis directly conflicts with what she consciously remembers about the night Chris died. He tells her not to go to Corfu. She’s not ready.
But she is already there.
Arriving at the Villa
Daphne has done a full renovation of the villa where they all stayed ten years ago. And Rowan is devastated by this, because it feels like Daphne has just erased every trace Chris ever existed in that place. Which, I understand that from a grief standpoint it might be easier, but also, your twin brother died there. The choices Daphne makes throughout this book are interesting and she definitely turns into a bit of a bridezilla.
Shay is there, and Rowan hasn’t seen him in years. He looks completely different. He’s shaved his head, he’s not drinking, he retired from sports last year because of an ACL injury. He’s made major life changes since that trip, and Rowan can’t tell if that’s grief over losing his best friend or something more.
The Recording
Rowan listens to the hypnosis session. And under hypnosis, she says it’s her fault Chris died. She saw him on the jetty that night, someone had their hands on his throat, fighting one of her friends. She uses her safeguard word to pull herself out of the memory before she says who.
So now she doesn’t know what to believe. Her conscious memory tells her she went to bed that night, but the recording says she saw something happen to Chris.
From Chris’s Perspective — Ten Years Ago
The book alternates between present-day Rowan and Chris’s point of view from ten years ago, and we start learning more about the trip as it actually was. Chris was struggling in a big way. He hadn’t gotten into photography school, he was feeling like a failure, and he’d also just found out something that hurt him: Shay had been interested in Rowan first, before Chris was, and Chris hadn’t realized how much he liked Rowan until Shay planned a move. He’d tried to discourage Shay from pursuing her, and it had worked, but now on this trip, Chris can see that Shay is trying to swoop in.
Daphne had also found out about Chris and Rowan from Chris himself, and her response was basically, oh interesting, because she used to talk a lot of trash about you. Not exactly the warm reception. But Chris and Rowan had kept this secret for a few months until Chris finally told her.
Chris also didn’t trust Matt, the guy Daphne would eventually marry. He thought he was a creep from day one. They all met Matt on this first trip to Corfu — Matt was originally interested in Zora, but Daphne kind of wedged her way in. That same night, Zora is raped. She initially thought it was by a biker guy, but all she remembers is flashes, and waking up in the alley.
Ketamine and Suspicion
Rowan had filed a freedom of information request after Chris’s death, so she has the official report. His blood alcohol was extremely high, and they also found ketamine in his system, which surprised Rowan because that wasn’t like him. She starts pointing fingers — first at Matt, then at Daphne, then at Zora, then at Shay. Everyone becomes a suspect at some point.
At the hen party, Rowan notices that both Matt and Zora are high, and that’s when she starts thinking Zora might have been the one who gave Chris the drugs.
Rowan Confronts Zora
She confronts her, and Zora denies it completely. And then Zora tells her something that reframes the whole thing: Chris was broken on that trip. He was depressed, he was struggling, and Zora thinks he went and got those drugs himself that night because he had spent the entire evening watching Rowan dance with Shay. He thought she wanted Shay, not him.
And that landed differently than I expected. Chris was genuinely suffering and nobody around him noticed.
From Chris’s Perspective — The Night He Died
From Chris’s POV we get the full picture. He had written Rowan a letter. He was ready to finally tell her what was going on with him, the depression, all of it, and then she’s on the dance floor, really close with Shay, and he completely loses it. He barges in and gets between them, there’s a fight, and then Rowan pushes him. He sits on the floor and nobody helps him. Rowan leaves with Shay’s arm around her. They kiss.
Chris goes to the bathroom, completely gutted. He shreds the letter. When he comes out, they’re gone. He runs after her, finds Shay and Rowan on the jetty together, and he attacks Shay. He’s choking him. Rowan manages to stop it, Chris lets Shay go, but she can see that Shay wants revenge.
The rest of the night plays out as Rowan remembers it: Chris leaves, Rowan goes to bed. Chris must have gone back to the bar.
The CCTV Footage
Rowan goes to the bar where Chris was last seen and convinces the woman there to show her the security footage. She’s watching it, fast-forwarding through, and she sees Matt order drinks at the bar, drug one of them, and slide it toward Zora. But Zora isn’t drinking anymore at that point in the night. So Chris, completely wrecked and devastated, grabs the drink and downs it himself. Zora comes back to the booth and can tell something’s wrong, but Matt reassures them all that Chris is fine. Chris passes out for a bit, then gets up and walks out to the jetty to pick up the necklace he’d given Rowan that came off in the earlier fight. And that’s when somebody hits him over the head and knocks him into the water.
The bar owner, Yanik, tells Rowan that once Matt’s rich father got involved, the police were only interested in looking the other way. He makes it very clear who he thinks should be in jail.
Confronting Daphne
Rowan and Shay decide to tell Daphne everything. They run into Zora, who finally admits what she’s known for a while: it was Matt who raped her that night, not some random stranger she initially thought it was. They go to Daphne with the CCTV footage, with all of it, and Daphne’s response is not what they were hoping for. She asks who else they’ve told. When they say no one, she says: Good. She’s not ready to believe it.
Matt walks in and Rowan can see it written all over his face. He keeps cutting Daphne off, trying to manage her, trying to get Rowan out of the room. His actual defense for drugging Chris is that he and Chris used to put stuff in each other’s drinks all the time. I cannot.
Daphne goes downstairs. The wedding, apparently, is still on.
Shay
While all of this is happening, Shay admits to Rowan that he has feelings for her. She admits it back. And then he tells her things that complicate everything she thought she knew about Chris: their first date was Shay’s idea, the necklace Chris gave her was Shay’s idea, Chris essentially took credit for a relationship Shay had helped build. And Rowan is upset, because suddenly her whole memory of Chris has a different color to it, and she’s not sure what was real.
She also wonders, for a moment, if Shay is the one who actually killed Chris that night. The book keeps you guessing.
The Wedding Day
Daphne walks down the aisle. And at the altar, Matt’s vows are generic and impersonal, and when Daphne gives her own long, heartfelt speech, he makes fun of the length of it in front of everyone. Just casually mocks her, and you can see Daphne realize, at that exact moment, exactly what she’s in for if she goes through with this. She says she can’t marry him. Matt tries to dismiss it as nerves. But Daphne walks away. She texts Rowan and asks her to come to her room. And the two of them decide, finally, to move forward together.
A Note on Narration
The narrator has a very heavy accent and I genuinely had trouble understanding parts of it. There’s a moment where I couldn’t make out what sport Shay had played professionally, and that kind of thing just pulls you right out of the story. I wouldn’t pick the audiobook for a second listen.
The Steam Rating Breakdown
🔥 — Nothing here. This is a mystery thriller and the romance between Rowan and Shay is mostly tension and suspicion. Zero steam.
The Ending Explained — Satisfied or Disappointed?
Honestly? A little flat for me. Matt is the killer (I think…), which the book infers fairly clearly once you realize how suspicious he’s been from the start. But it never did say for sure. Also — was there ever an arrest? Any consequences for Matt? The emotional payoff with Daphne walking away from the wedding at the altar worked for me, but I wanted more from the actual resolution. We get the truth, Daphne leaves Matt, Rowan and Shay find each other, but the sense of real justice isn’t quite there.
Would I Reread It?
No. It was just a very slow listen, and the narrator made it harder than it needed to be.
Who Is This For
If you like destination wedding thrillers with a dual timeline, unreliable memory as a plot device, and a slow-burn mystery that keeps shifting the suspect list, you might get more out of this than I did. Go in with patience for the pacing, and maybe try the physical book instead of the audio.
Where to Get This Book
🎧 Audiobook
Audible US | Audible CA
🎁 New to Audible? Get 3 months free (US)
Ready for more from LD? Find them here
Plot Twisted. 🔥
🎧 | Standalone | Genre: Thriller | Steam: 🔥