🎧 Reviewed by LD | Rating: 4.6/5 | Steam: 🔥
⚠️ This is a full spoiler review. If you haven’t read The Stone Sisters yet — go read it first. We’ll be here when you’re done.
The Opening
I picked this one completely blind. New release, included in my Audible membership, didn’t even read the description before I started listening. I still wasn’t entirely sure what I was listening to for the first little while. What I can tell you is that by the end I was completely hooked and genuinely glad I took the shot.
The Full Story — Spoilers Included
The Format
The book opens with an interview and has other interview snippets interspersed throughout. It’s an odd format but it works once you settle into it. Those interview sections are Blithe painting herself as a wonderful mother and devoted wife while everything else in the book shows you exactly who she actually is. The contrast is the point, but it feels strange for the first half of the book.
Blithe
Blithe is a straightforward narcissist. She blames her daughters for everything, takes credit for their successes, steals their ideas, and has spent their entire lives making them feel like inconveniences she was burdened with. She has three daughters: Alison, Kit, and Grace. Each of them has a story that tells you exactly who their mother is.
When Alison was a kid they were on a ski trip. Alison didn’t want to ski anymore — she was tired and cold. Blithe forced her to keep going, then immediately ditched her on the slopes. Alison slipped on ice and broke her leg, lying on the ski hill alone waiting for her mother to realize she needed help. When she was home recovering, Blithe came upstairs and showed her the $900 medical bill, told her that because of her “dramatics” they wouldn’t be able to rent the cabin they’d planned on that summer. This was apparently Alison’s fault for having the audacity to slip on ice. They rented the cabin anyway. Alison knew they weren’t poor. She knew it wasn’t her fault, but that type of thing stays with you forever.
Kit’s story is different but equally telling. She was engaged, had a wedding planned, and six months before the date her fiancé called it off, admitting he’d let things go on too long. On the day they were supposed to be married, Blithe got married instead — and she sent Kit’s ex-fiancé a personal handwritten note making sure he attended. The man who broke her daughter’s heart. Blithe intentionally invited him and, it turns out, had offered him a job at her company while simultaneously trying to force her daughter to work there too.
Grace has always known her mother hates her specifically. She has never understood why, because how could a child ever make sense of that. Eventually her mother tells her she had wanted a boy and Grace was just such a disappointment — simply because she is female. Interesting that same logic did not apply to Kit, the youngest daughter.
The Terrible Things Blithe Does
An article comes out destroying Alison’s reputation. A former assistant had gone to Blithe first trying to blackmail her, claiming negative information about Alison. Blithe told her she doesn’t hire blackmailers and suggested she’d be better off selling it to a news outlet. So that is exactly what the woman did. Blithe essentially pointed a loaded gun at her own daughter and told someone else to pull the trigger.
Kit has been developing her own business and brings Blithe a proposal. Blithe turns her down, tells her she has no idea what she’s doing, and offers her a position at the family company to handle a Target collaboration. Then she hands Kit a folder of the collaboration designs. They are all Kit’s own designs, fully ripped off from the proposal Kit had given her months earlier. Word for word, piece for piece, identical. Blithe made fun of Kit’s pottery and then stole every single one of her ideas. Because it would benefit her.
At Blithe’s wedding she announces in front of everyone that all three of her daughters have decided to join the family company. Not one of them had committed to this. They had all left it at we’ll think about it. Alison pipes up in front of the room and says clearly that she is not joining — she has her own business, and if she didn’t correct it right then her investors would drop out. Everyone holds their breath waiting for the fallout.
Blithe pulls her aside. We don’t hear what is said until much later.
The Death
The next morning Alison’s husband wakes her up. There are paramedics. Police. Blithe’s new husband is soaked in blood. Blithe is dead.
What unravels across the rest of the book is that each sister had a hand in it, each thinking she was the one who actually killed their mother, each quietly sheltering the other two.
Alison gave Blithe Xanax. She had slipped the benzos into her mother’s champagne glass during their private conversation. She washed out the glass afterward to remove the evidence. She made the decision somewhere in that room and followed through with it.
Grace went to the club room that night intending to confront her mother. She found Blithe there, drunk she thought, though we know it was the benzos. Blithe started in on her daughters and admitted to Grace specifically that she had never loved her. Not her sisters. Just Grace. Grace hit her mother over the head with a wine bottle in a blind rage, hid the bottle, and went calmly back to her room.
Kit went to the club room looking for a snack. Found her mother on the floor. Felt for a pulse. Her mother’s eyes opened. Kit thought about helping her and then realized she didn’t want to. She couldn’t live under her weight anymore. She held her hand over her mother’s mouth until the lights went out.
All three of them thought they were the one. Kit is the one who actually finished it. But every one of them got there.
Blithe and Tad
At the end of the book we get a flash to the night the girls’ father Tad died. Blithe came home from a trip, was furious he hadn’t prepared for her arrival, and was already thinking about her long-running affair with James, the man she eventually marries. She stormed back in from a walk to find Tad on the floor having a heart attack. She stood there and held eye contact while he died, then lied about having found him dead when she got home.
The affairs, the company she allegedly stole the idea for, the husband she let die, the daughters she spent decades tearing down. Blithe Stone was a genuinely terrible person.
Best Part of This Book
The ending reveal. Finding out that all three sisters each believed they were the one who killed their mother, each quietly carrying it to protect the others, while Kit was the one who actually finished the job. It reframes everything you thought you understood about the night Blithe died and it is genuinely well done.
The Steam Rating Breakdown
🔥 — Zero romance, zero heat. This is a psychological family drama with a murder mystery at its center. Content warnings for narcissistic abuse, child neglect, theft, infidelity, and a deeply satisfying villain death.
The Ending — Satisfied or Disappointed?
Satisfied. Murder is not great. But Blithe Stone let her husband die on the floor rather than call for help and spent thirty years destroying her daughters from the inside out. I am not going to pretend I felt bad about how this ended for her.
Would I Reread It?
Maybe. I’m not sure yet. But I’m still thinking about it, which says something.
Who Is This For
Anyone who loves a psychological thriller with a genuinely compelling villain and a twist ending that earns itself. Readers who don’t need a romance to be invested in a story. Anyone who has ever had a complicated relationship with a parent who made them feel like a burden rather than a person — this one will hit differently.
Where to Get
The Stone Sisters is an Audible Original — available exclusively as an audiobook.
🎧 Audiobook
Audible
🎁 New to Audible? Get 3 months free (US)
🎁 New to Libro.fm? Get 2 free audiobooks
Ready for more from LD? Find them here